Before the village
The land along the upper Des Plaines River was Potawatomi country, and the trails they traveled later became Milwaukee Avenue. In the early 1830s English settler George Vardin brought his family here, and the small settlement took the name Vardin’s Grove. Residents renamed it Independence Grove at the July 4 celebration in 1836.
When the post office opened in Vardin’s former cabin on April 16, 1837, another Illinois post office was already using Independence Grove, so it was registered as Libertyville. When the county was formed in 1839, Libertyville became its first seat, going by Burlington for a time. The seat moved to Little Fort, later Waukegan, in 1841, and the town took back the name Libertyville.
Market town to railroad village
From 1841 to 1880 Libertyville was a rural market town, with about 220 residents by 1880. Ansel Brainerd Cook, a Chicago contractor and civic figure, built his house on Milwaukee Avenue in 1878. The Milwaukee and St. Paul Railroad came through in 1881, and in April 1882 Libertyville incorporated as a village with John Locke as its first president.
The 1895 fire
On August 31, 1895, fire started behind George Schanck’s hardware store near Milwaukee and Cook avenues. Bucket brigades did the work, merchandise was carried onto the Cook lawn, and some buildings were dynamited. Much of the east side of downtown was lost. Afterward the village required new downtown buildings to be brick, organized a volunteer fire department and bought its first fire engine. Many of the brick storefronts on Milwaukee Avenue date from that rebuilding.
A growing suburb
Regular commuter rail service arrived in 1900, a second rail connection followed in 1903, and utilities came to town. Samuel Insull built an estate south of the village, and architect David Adler made his country home north of downtown. After Emily Cook’s death the Cook house and grounds were given to the village; the house served as the public library from 1921 to 1968, and the land became Cook Park. The original Liberty Theatre opened in 1937. The population went from about 3,930 in 1940 to 8,560 in 1960.
Keeping the history
The Libertyville-Mundelein Historical Society, now the Libertyville Historical Society, was founded in 1955. The new Cook Memorial Library opened in 1968, and the Cook home became the society’s headquarters and museum. In 1980 the Adler estate opened as the David Adler Cultural Center.
In the late 20th century, downtown restoration, Cook Park as a gathering place and a walkable Milwaukee Avenue full of independent shops and restaurants shaped the village people know today, and the population more than doubled between 1960 and 2000. The Cook House, the David Adler Estate and the Proctor Building carry local landmark recognition, and downtown has its own local historic district. In April 2025 the Libertyville Downtown Historic District was added to the National Register of Historic Places, honoring the buildings around Milwaukee Avenue, including those that rose after the 1895 fire.
Source: Village of Libertyville: History of Libertyville · Cook Memorial Public Library: The Great Libertyville Fire of 1895 · Libertyville Historical Society: Ansel B. Cook Home · Village of Libertyville: Historic Surveys and Records